The Garrett Presbyterian Church was organized in 1905 and they met in an old German Methodist Church building until 1919 when they became joint owners of St. Matthew's Reformed Church. St. Matthew's was built around 1904 and both congregations were thriving, until the Baltimore & Ohio shops left town. By 1919 both congregations were struggling to afford their buildings, so they decided to join together as the Reformed-Presbyterian Church. At some point the 'Reformed' was dropped and the church became simply Garrett Presbyterian Church. Many improvements have been made to the building throughout the years, including limestone and brick veneers in 1966.

Throughout the years the congregation has been active in the community and their building has been continually in use for ministry to their neighborhood.

Garrett Presbyterian Church